Introduction:
Recent technological breakthroughs in the development of high end
computer architectures
combined with new and novel approaches in
high performance software methods, have provided the computational
chemistry/physics community with the resources needed to address
progressively more complex and difficult scientific problems. The
presently available, and rapidly evolving, state-of-the-art
hardware/software tools allows scientists to expand the scope and
complexity of the systems and processes under investigation. In many
cases, this has allowed us to tackle ``real world'' problems that were
previously computationally intractable. It is now becoming possible to
understand how molecular level events influence important processes in
the environment, materials design, biological organisms, and many
other systems. These technological breakthroughs require us to expand
the vision of our scientific inquiry beyond traditional boundaries and
present us with a tremendously exciting and scientifically challenging
environment.
Scientific inquires must keep pace with the rapidly advancing computer industry. New scientific disciplines such as molecular environmental science and molecular biochemistry are, in part, products of the recent ``technological revolution.'' Major breakthroughs in these and related fields will be possible if we can understand the underlying molecular processes that control our world. In order to realize these goals, it is imperative that the scientific research community continues to forge strong links with computer developers and computer scientists. The crucial link between these areas is the development of high performance software that can utilize the hardware's full potential. A symbiotic relationship must exist between the theoretical chemical physics community and computer scientists and designers in order to continue to expand our scientific horizons.
Theoretical Chemical Physics at PNNL:
Rapidly evolving high performance computer technologies allow us to probe complex problems in molecular chemistry/physics at many different levels. One approach is to use and develop these resources in order to examine the properties of ``large length scale'' systems - e.g. (10-1000+) atom clusters, nanoparticles, liquids, solids and homogeneous and heterogeneous interfaces. Understanding the underlying physics and chemistry of these systems provides us with insight into the behavior of many environmentally and industrially important processes including, the transport of contaminants through soils, the separation of heavy metals and radionuclides from liquid hazardous wastes, the development of efficient and more cost effective catalysts, the effect of heterogeneous reaction chemistry on atmospheric and terrestrial cycles, the development of bioremediation methods. These studies employ a range of methods from ab initio quantum mechanics to classical simulation techniques. The level of theory used to study a particular system depends on the nature of the problem, the size and complexity of the system, and the availability of sufficient computational resources (both hardware and software).
An alternate approach employs state-of-the-art computational resources to study complex electronic process (e.g. basis set development, reaction rate theory, electron-electron correlation effects, many body theories) in ``small length scale'' molecular or atomic systems. These scientific inquires are the basis for understanding the fundamental properties of molecules and their extended assemblages, including important information about interaction energies and reaction rates. This information is essential for developing quantitatively precise models that can predict the outcome of complex industrial and environmental processes. Highly accurate theoretical models (``computer experiments'') are often more cost effective and efficient than the corresponding laboratory or field studies and hence, are a fundamental component of research in fields ranging from environmental to biomedical to materials research.
Research in the Molecular Theory and Modeling program focuses on understanding the role that molecular processes play in condensed phases, characteristic of natural and contaminated environments. This research program integrates ab initio studies of fundamental molecular processes in model systems with modeling of the complex molecular systems found in the environment. This integrated approach is computationally demanding and relies heavily on the accessibility and utility of high-end computational resources.
The objectives of this research program are:
Applications in this program focus on four overlapping research areas: cluster chemistry, solution-phase chemistry, separations chemistry, and chemistry at interfaces. A common element in each of these areas is the need to understand molecular interactions in aqueous solutions or at environmentally-important interfaces such as the interfaces between aqueous solutions and air, other liquids (e.g., organic solutions), minerals, and glasses. The development of new theoretical methods for treating these problems is concentrated in the areas of electronic structure method, reaction rate theory, and classical model development. The range and extent of these theoretical efforts are closely coupled to advances made in high-end computer architectures.
Examples from the four research areas - cluster chemistry, solution-phase chemistry, separations chemistry and interface chemistry - are described below. These examples are meant to illustrate the importance of high-end computing for solving complex problems in environmental molecular research.
Cluster Chemistry
Research in cluster chemistry is focused on the structure and properties of aqueous clusters and on the energetics and dynamics of molecular processes involving such clusters. Molecular clusters offer a unique opportunity to examine the transition from the gaseous phase to condensed phases and to enhance our understanding of the intermolecular interactions between solutes and water. In addition, to the extent that clusters model the solution phase, studies of molecular clusters provide an opportunity to ascertain the effects of solvation on chemical reactions: comparison of the pathways, energetics and dynamics of the ``solvated'' reaction with the gas-phase reaction will lead to insights into the detailed role that the solvent plays in altering the mechanism and rates of reactions in solution.
The methodologies developed to model gas-phase molecules and molecular processes are being applied to the study of the aqueous clusters. However, solution of the electronic and nuclear Schrödinger equation for aqueous clusters poses two challenges. First, the number of atoms involved in the calculations increases with the size of the cluster and accurate calculations rapidly become intractable. Second, the resulting potential energy surface possesses multiple minima that complicates the characterization and representation of the potential surface and subsequent dynamical studies. The primary focus of work in this area is the understanding of the structure and energetics of aqueous clusters and the development of improved interaction models for these systems.
Ab Initio Studies of M+(H2O)n and M2+(H2O)n Clusters
Reliable theoretical data on the structure and energetics of small water clusters containing alkali or alkaline earth ions (Li+ through Cs+ and Mg2+ through Ra2+) are of interest due to the widespread appearance of such systems in nature and the difficulty of obtaining this information experimentally. Furthermore, the data is of interest because the observed binding preferences of crown ethers for particular cations in aqueous solution involves a competition between the binding of the ion to water and to 18-crown-6. The ion selectivity properties of crown ether complexes makes them unique materials for understanding enzyme chemistry and designing ion-separation techniques. This process can be modeled by calculating the energetics of the exchange reactions:
M+(H2O)n + M
(18-crown-6)
M
(H2O)n + M+(18-crown-6)
M2+(H2O)n + M
(18-crown-6)
M
(H2O)n + M2+(18-crown-6)
This competition between water-ion and crown ether-ion interactions is most easily determined theoretically because the synthesis of these materials is very complex.
Geometries, binding energies, and enthalpies of molecular clusters
incorporating a single metal ion and up through 8 waters were
determined using basis sets and levels of theory comparable to those
employed in a parallel study of ion/18-crown-6 systems. Most
calculations were done with the polarized 6-31+G* basis set and second
order perturbation theory. In order to estimate the inherent accuracy
in the MP2/6-31+G* level of theory, some of the same clusters were
re-examined with more elaborate theoretical methods. This calibration
study involved the use of the correlation consistent sequence of basis
sets to estimate the complete basis set limit, coupled with higher
order correlation methods (e.g. MP4 and CCSD(T)). Representative
results for Li+(H2O) and Na+(H2O) are shown in Figure 12.
![]() |
Excellent agreement is observed between counterpoise (CP) corrected
6-31+G* results and the best theoretical values. Slightly poorer
agreement is seen in the metal-oxygen distance because of the lack of
a basis set superposition correction. In general the effects of
correlation recovery on the basic cation-water distance and binding
energy is small (
0.03 Åand
2 kcal/mol, respectively).
However, as the clusters increase in size and the potential for
multiple water-water interactions increases, the importance of
correlation effects also increase.
Due to the time consuming nature of large-basis-set, correlated calculations, we are limited in our ability to carry out the highest quality calculation to clusters containing no more than five or six waters. Such calculations require hundreds of hours on conventional supercomputers like the Cray C90. For example, a single point MP2 calculation on K+(H2O)6 using a Dunning aug-cc-pVDZ basis set (277 functions) takes about 8 CPU hours using 30 Mwords of memory and 2 GB of scratch disk space on a C90. Improved algorithms for optimizing the structure of floppy systems and computationally cheaper theoretical methods are both needed, along with new computer architectures, such as massively parallel machines. We are currently investigating density functional theory with non-local gradient corrections and the ``Resolution of the Identify MP2'' method.
Solution Phase Chemistry
Solution-phase chemistry plays a central role in the Molecular Theory and Modeling program. The effort is focused on the structure, energetics and dynamics of molecular processes in aqueous solutions. This work is the basis for an enhanced understanding of molecular processes occurring in contaminated and natural ground-water and in complex waste solutions. This core program in solution chemistry is designed to further the understanding of the fundamental molecular processes occurring in solution (e.g., solvation and reaction), providing a basis for the development of accurate techniques for simulating the behavior of complex waste solutions. This work includes studies of ionic solvation, supercritical fluids, and solvent effects on chemical reactions.
Molecular dynamics simulations of liquid-liquid interface with polarizable potential models
An understanding of ion transport mechanisms across the interface of two immiscible liquids is fundamental to electrochemistry and surfactant chemistry. It is also closely related to environmental problems such as separations chemistry that is performed in binary solvent systems (i.e., organic and aqueous phases) and interactions of contaminated organic solvents with ground water. We begin our effort in this area by examining the equilibrium properties of the CCl4/H2O liquid-liquid interface using molecular dynamics (MD) simulation techniques. It is well known that some of the properties of H2O and CCl4 near the CCl4/H2O interface are significantly different from their respective bulk properties. For instance, differences in the hydrogen bonding network and/or orientation preferred by the water molecules at the liquid/vapor interface results in a change in the dipole moment from 2.6 - 2.8 D in the bulk to 2.2 - 2.3 D at the interface. Thus, it is instructive to include the non-additive effects in describing solvation properties at the interface.
Computer simulations of liquid-liquid interfaces have been reported by
Benjamin and coworkers on the structure, dynamics and conformational
equilibria at the water/1,2-dichloro-ethane liquid-liquid interface and
subsequently the mechanism of ion transport across this interface.
Work has also been done on the transport of water molecules through a
lipid membrane and on the water/hexane liquid-liquid interface by
Berendsen and coworkers, and on the problem of solute transfer across
a liquid/liquid interface by Hayoun et al. All of these studies of the
liquid-liquid interfaces employ pair-wise additive models. Thus, the
effects of including polarization on the liquid-liquid interfacial
equilibrium properties are not known. We report here a molecular
dynamics study of the CCl4/H2O liquid-liquid interface using
polarizable potential models. This particular interface is of great
environmental importance. Due to its usage in the processing of the
radioactive materials, CCl4 contributes significantly to the
problem of nuclear waste remediation. A detailed investigation of the
CCl4/H2O liquid-liquid interface at a molecular level should aid
in solving these environmental problems. In this work, we are able to
describe the electrical properties (i.e. the induced and the total
dipole moments) of the CCl4 and H2O molecules as a function of
their distance normal to the interface. In Figure 13, we
present the computed CCl4/H2O interface density profile averaged
over a 100 ps simulation as a function of the z axis normal to the
interface.
![]() |
The density profiles are calculated using slab thickness of 1Å parallel to the XY plane. After closely examining the Figure 13, we observe that the interface is not molecularly sharp, and that the density profile of H2O indicates no layering and it is similar to that obtained for the water liquid-vapor interface using our polarizable potential model. The individual density profiles of H and O atoms are also identical to the corresponding to that of H2O. The density profile of CCl4, on the other hand, exhibits some oscillations. This is maybe due to the small number of CCl4 molecules used as compared to that of water. The simulations with a significantly longer trajectory and larger system size are in progress to evaluate the origin of these oscillations. During the dynamic simulation, the interfacial fluctuations are monitored by computing the interfacial width as a function of time (the results are not shown here). We find that the width is oscillating, which indicates that there are some penetrations and retreats by water and carbon tetrachloride molecules between the interface regions.
To understand the effect of the polarization effects on the electrical properties of water molecules near the interface, we calculate the total dipole moments of the water molecules as a function of Z axis normal to the interface, and the results are shown in Figure 14.
The dipole moments are computed using slab thickness of 1Å parallel to the XY plane. Examining this figure, several observations are in order:
![]() |
As expected, the average induced dipole moment of water molecules near
the interface are rather small compared to water molecules in
bulk-like regions. The induced dipole moment of carbon tetrachloride
molecules near the interface regions significantly increase, which may
be explained by the presence of the local electric field induced by
the water molecules at the interface.The static orientations of the
CCl4 - H2O near the interface are examined via the angular
distribution functions as a function of C - O separation, and are
presented in Figure 16.
![]() |
The angle is defined between the intramolecular C - Cl bond and the
vector connecting the oxygen and carbon atom. When the C - O distance
is around 3Å, the computed angular distribution functions show
dramatic deviations from the sine curve that describes a uniform
distribution. Two peaks centered at 72
and 170
are observed for a C - O distance less than 4Å, while the
probability of finding CCl4 in other orientations with respect to
H2O is almost vanished. Integrating over the area under these two
peaks gives a ratio of magnitude of roughly 3:1.
This implies that each CCl4 molecule has three of its chlorine atoms facing O, while the fourth chlorine atom sits on the opposite side of the central carbon atom away from O in an almost linear arrangement. This result suggests that water molecules induce a strong orientational order on the CCl4 molecules near the interface, which is consistent with the increasing of the induced dipole moment of the CCl4 molecules. As the C - O separation becomes larger (i.e., >5Å), the angular distribution curve behaves as a normal sine function, indicating the orientational order has been smeared out and the influences of water molecules on the carbon tetrachloride molecules have diminished. To our knowledge, this work is the first MD simulation on the liquid-liquid interfacial equilibrium properties that explicitly includes non-additive effects. As expected, the interface is not molecularly sharp. The density of water indicates a uniform distribution while that corresponding for the CCl4 exhibits some oscillations. This oscillatory behavior deserves further investigation which is in progress.
Separations Chemistry
Research in separations chemistry concentrates on the structure and energetics of ion-ligand complexes (such as crown ethers) and the dynamics of complex formation in aqueous solutions. The goal of this effort is to discover the factors that control the selectivity and efficiency of ligating species important in the pretreatment of nuclear and chemical wastes.
To date, this effort has focused on the crown ethers. Crown ethers have drawn much experimental and theoretical interest since they were first described by Pederson in 1967. These cyclic polyethers can form remarkably stable complexes with alkali- and alkaline-earth metal cations. Furthermore, the selectivity of this binding is sensitive to macrocycle ring size, ether-heteroatom, and macrocycle substituents. The ion specificity of crown-ethers makes them attractive as models for understanding enzyme chemistry as well as ligands useful to aid cleanup of mixed wastes that contain radionuclides such as cesium (Cs+) and strontium (Sr2+), and transuranic ions.
Combined Ab Initio and Experimental Studies of Small Ether/Cation Clusters
The only previous direct experimental measurement of the gas-phase
binding energy of alkali metal cations and 18-crown-6 found values
considerably smaller than our ab initio results. For example, their
ion-cyclotron-resonance binding enthalpy for K+:18-crown-6 at 350 K
was -40
8 kcal/mol, compared to an MP2 value of -72 kcal/mol.
To shed light on underlying sources of error in the theoretical
numbers, a joint experimental/theoretical investigation was begun on
the binding energies of alkali cations with small ethers (e.g.,
dimethyl ether, dimethoxy ethane and 12-crown-4). While the results
of that study are still in a preliminary stage, to date there have
been no instances of deviations greater than
2 kcal/mol. The
theoretical approach employed the same basis sets and levels of theory
which were used in the earlier crown ether study. As seen in Figure
17 the counterpoise corrected MP2/6-31+G* binding energy is in
remarkable agreement with the apparent complete basis set limit.
![]() |
Mechanism and Thermodynamics of Ion Selectivity in Aqueous Solutions of 18-Crown-6 Ether: A Molecular Dynamics Study
We have performed an extensive classical molecular dynamics simulation to examine the mechanism and thermodynamics for ion selectivity in aqueous solutions of 18-crown-6 ether. 18-crown-6 is one of the most extensive studied crown systems and the abundance of the experimental data for these systems provide a good prototype model to verify our approach. To the best of our knowledge, the present work is the first application of the potential of mean force approach to the evaluation of ion selectivity by crown ethers in aqueous solutions. Our simulations differ from previous work in that the free energies of complexation are computed as a function of the ion-crown separation, or potential of mean force (PMF). This makes the current study valuable for several reasons. First, the computed PMF allows us to examine the minima positions of the complexes and they can be related directly to the x-ray data. The second valuable aspect is that we can compute the absolute binding energies by integrating over the PMFs, the resultants can be directly compared with the corresponding experimental measurements. The third advantage of our approach is that we can examine the role of solvent effects along the reaction coordinate (i.e., contact pair or solvent separated pair).
The free energy profiles or PMF for M+:18-crown-6 (M+ = K+,
Na+, Rb+, Cs+) complexation are computed via the free energy
perturbation method. Counterion effects are considered and all
long-range interactions are computed via the Ewald summation method.
The resultant PMFs indicate that free-energy minima for the K+ and
Na+ ions are located at the crown ether center-of-mass as shown in
Figure 18(a). Potassium is selected over sodium because of the
greater free energy penalty associated with displacing water molecules
from sodium as it approaches the crown ether. This leads to a
substantial increase in the activation free energy and a decrease in
the binding free energy for Na+:18-crown-6 complexation as compared
to K+:18-crown-6. The selection of potassium over rubidium and
cesium is due to the cation-size relative to the crown-ether cavity.
The calculated PMFs for all the ions are shown in Figure
18(a). We computed binding free energies by integrating
over the PMFs and the results are summarized in Figure
18(b). They are slightly underestimated, although, they
follow the sequence K+ > Rb+ > Cs+ > Na+ reported
experimentally. The shortcoming in binding free energies can be
overcome by improving the cation-crown ether interaction potential
and/or taking to account the non-additive effects in these molecular
systems. Studies on these and the related questions are in progress.
![]() |
Chemistry at Interfaces
Research on the chemistry at interfaces includes studies of aqueous interfaces with air (or vapor), other liquids (e.g., carbon tetrachloride), crystalline solids (e.g., mineral oxides, clays, found in soils), and glasses. The studies of air-vapor interfaces are important to understanding heterogeneous processes that occur in the atmosphere. The studies of liquid-liquid interfaces is important to understanding the transport of molecules and ions between two immiscible liquids, which is relevant in a number of field such as electrochemistry, separations, and the interaction of contaminated organic solvents with ground water. The studies of aqueous-mineral interfaces is important to understanding the binding of contaminants to the soil. The studies of glass-water interfaces provides information on the dissolution and degradation of materials that are being proposed for long term storage of nuclear wastes.
Heterogeneous and interfacial systems are exceptionally challenging systems to study theoretically. The complex chemistry and physics occurring in these systems over large length and time scales requires extensive compute power to probe and predict experimental observables. To accomplish this task many new and inventive theoretical methodologies must be used and developed. Integrated methods that exploit the accuracy of ab initio quantum mechanical theories with the speed and time-dependent properties of classical mechanics are essential for examining complex interfacial phenomena. The development of efficient methods of this type is currently an area of active research that requires high end computer platforms. Future work in this field will utilize these compute resources to address more complex, ``real world'' problems.
Physics and Chemistry of Structurally Simple Oxides
The chemistry of naturally occurring and/or industrially important interfaces often involves dynamical processes of structurally and electronically complex materials. In particular, it is necessary to determine the properties of realistic surface sites (containing point defects, steps, kinks) to quantitatively predict surface chemistry. Magnesium oxide (MgO) is a structurally simple cubic oxide material whose interfaces play an important role in subsurface geochemistry, catalysis and materials design. The bulk, surface and interface properties of MgO are being studied to understand the behavior of MgO and to derive models that can be used to model processes involving more complex oxides. The composition (number of electrons) and structure (high symmetry) make this a ``computationally practical'' system that can be studied in detail using periodic ab initio electronic structure theory.
Research in this area probed several different problems. The electronic structure investigations of the MgO/water interface were extended to examine the effect of defect sites on the surface chemistry. Water is ever-present in the environment and can have a variety of interactions with exposed oxide surfaces, each of which will have a different effect on soil chemistry and on the transport of other chemicals through soils. Therefore, understanding the processes of water adsorption and chemical dissociation on oxide surfaces is fundamental to modeling subsurface transport phenomena. Ab initio periodic Hartree Fock (PHF) theory (including correlation corrections) was used to study the chemistry of water on clean, defected and strained MgO (001).
Structural defects were constructed containing both corner
(3-coordinated) and edge (4-coordinated) sites. Isotropic distortions
of the lattice probed the properties of strained MgO. The ab initio
energetics revealed that molecular water binds weakly
(
10-15 kcal/mol) to flat MgO (100) and more strongly (17-25
kcal/mol) to the defected sites. Mulliken populations show that a
fundamental change occurs in the surface oxygen sites as the
coordination number of these sites decreases while the magnesium sites
remain relatively unaffected by changes in their local environment.
The reduction of the Madelung field surrounding the oxygen sites
results in the migration of small amounts of charge from the surface
oxygens to oxygens residing in the bulk material leaving the oxygen
defect sites capable of forming more strongly covalent bonds than
sites on the perfect surface. Chemidissociation - resulting in
surface hydroxylation - is found only to occur on surface defect sites
and not on the equilibrium structure flat surface. However,
chemidissociation becomes more energetically favorable as the flat
lattice is isotropically distorted (becoming exothermic with
5-8% dilation of the lattice constant). This data indicates
that the surface chemistry of MgO could be adjusted if stable thin
films of the material could be prepared under strained conditions.
The dramatically different chemistry on defected, clean and strained
surfaces illustrates, quantitatively, the importance of surface
structure in regulating interfacial phenomena. Analytic expressions
for the water/MgO (001) interaction potential were derived from the
quantum mechanical data and are currently being used in classical
simulations to examine the dynamical properties of the interface.
A new methodology was also developed to derive electrostatic models of oxide interfaces. These models are constructed from the energetics of an adsorbate - described by a multipolar expansion of the charge density - interacting with the quantum mechanical electric fields generated by the surface.
The terms on the right hand side of this expression represent the
interaction of a charged species with the surface potential, a
permanent dipole with the field, and a molecular quadrapole with the
field gradient. The field generated by the surface and the moments of
the adsorbate are computed quantum mechanically and the
adsorbate-surface interaction is deduced from the classical
electrostatic interaction (eq. 4). This electrostatic
model produces a reliable computationally ``trivial'' method for
examining the properties of a range of interfaces. The results have
been validated by comparing the classical data to quantum mechanical
calculations on several systems. Excellent agreement was found
between the computed electrostatic energetics and the quantum
mechanical values for HCl, H2O and NH3 on MgO (see Figure 19).
This approach provides us with a quantitative interpretation of the
interfacial bonding interactions that allow us to predict the
properties of more complex, low symmetry materials.
![]() |